McIntosh Law
Speak With Our Attorneys -
Phone: 941-306-3230
View Our Practice Areas

Florida rules against state attorney's no-death-penalty idels

In Florida, the state attorney had filed a petition challenging the governor's authority to reassign death penalty cases. The court recently ruled that the governor is within his rights to reassign the prosecution of death-penalty cases to a special prosecutor.

Why does that matter to the state attorney? She previously had a run-in with the governor when the attorney decided that she would not seek the death penalty against a man who is accused of fatally shooting his ex-girlfriend, a woman who was pregnant at the time. She also determined she would not seek the death penalty for any other case that came to her during her tenure.

As a result, the governor reassigned 29 cases to another state attorney after indicating that the woman was not following Florida law. She argued that he should not be able to take cases from her due to her being independently elected to her position. The governor's attorney claimed that the governor could reassign the cases if the woman wouldn't do her job, and a blanket refusal to seek a death penalty was just that. At best, the court claims, it shows that she does not understand Florida law.

On first-degree murder charges, the court ruled that case-specific determinations must be made. For your case, that may be good news. If the court had allowed any state attorney to paint all cases with one brush, it could have meant seeking the death penalty for any first-degree murder case instead of not doing so. Your case has its own specific evidence and situational concerns. The courts in Florida now realize that.

Source: WFTV 9, "Florida Supreme Court rules against Ayala on Scott's reassigning of death penalty cases," Field Sutton, Aug. 31, 2017

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information
  • Avvo Rating 9.6 | Brett Donald McIntosh | Top Attorney
  • Avvo | Clients' Choice Award 2016 | Brett Donald McIntosh
  • Reviews | 5 stars Out of 16 reviews | Brett Donald McIntosh | Avvo
Email Us For A Response

Get Started Today

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy


McIntosh Law
766 Hudson Avenue
Suite B
Sarasota, FL 34236

Toll Free: 866-943-0466
Phone: 941-306-3230
Fax: 941-957-0706
Sarasota Law Office Map